Through our portfolio of services, we help you make informed decisions about the leadership you need to build an organization that outperforms, inspires and grows.
We help you find and develop outstanding leaders, improve team and board performance, and align culture with your strategy.
Explore our insights on leadership, board and governance issues, organizational culture and more.
How can you foster more effective top teams, make more informed choices about leadership and improve the odds of merger success? Read more.
We have 60 years’ experience in leadership consulting. We've built a reputation for delivering real impact for our clients — from the world’s largest companies to startups to nonprofits.
We are committed to building relationships with exceptional leaders who may qualify as candidates, now or in the future. To maximize your visibility, we encourage you to register with both Spencer Stuart and BlueSteps.
Spencer Stuart uses cookies that are essential for this site to function well. Please click “Accept” to help us improve its usefulness with additional cookies. Learn about our use of cookies and collaboration with trusted partners in our Cookie Policy.
Is experience always better? Conventional wisdom suggests it is. When making a difficult decision, people tend to go with the “safe choice,” rather than a riskier option with a greater potential upside. In the boardroom, this tendency can translate into a preference for experienced CEOs in CEO selection. And, indeed, the share of S&P 500 CEOs with prior experience has grown from 4% to 16% since 1997.
The Jan-Feb 2021 issue of Harvard Business Review highlights findings from a Spencer Stuart study about the benefits and limits of potential and prior CEO experience. The study examined the performance of 855 S&P 500 CEOs appointed over a 20-year period, finding that CEOs with prior experience in the role underperformed first-time CEOs over the medium to long term. First-timers led their companies to higher market-adjusted total shareholder returns over the course of their tenure, with less volatility in the stock price. The study also provided advice to boards about how to select the CEO who is most likely to succeed given the opportunities and challenges the company faces.
Access the article below by visiting hbr.org or clicking on the link to the pdf below.